Caterpillar Carnage

I hooked the caterpillar out from the remains of the kale plant with a stick and pushed it down into the soil. It sunk from view. I then continued to snip the savaged leaves of my Red Russian and Cavolo Nero kales right back to disheartening stumps. But in the back of my mind the caterpillar just kept haunting me. What if it recovered from the squishing and, half-dead but still evil of intent, managed to drag itself back up the kale plant and continue its appalling mission? I dug it up again and cut it in half with a pair of secateurs. Green slime oozed out and it lay in two furry black, yellow and white halves.

I then moved on to the smaller lighter-green
caterpillars and cut those in half too, before stamping on some bunchy little beige slugs, throwing a few snails against the wall with a satisfying crack and, just because I felt like it, eclipsing a small passing fly between two clapped hands. God, it felt good. I used to be so squeamish I couldn't lift up a garden stone for fear of what might be lurking beneath it. Now I prowl around knee-deep in vegetation searching for pests with "bare hands", and positively revel in slaughter.

Alex Mitchell

I'd worry about it if I thought I was alone. But anyone who gardens knows the visceral thrill of mashing aphids between thumb and forefinger and is familiar with the lemon curd innards of a stamped-on chafer grub.
Even the knit-your-own-yoghurt, sprouting-seed-eating hippy becomes a blank-eyed killer when faced with the destruction of a row of cut-and-come-again lettuce. Even the most militantly organic grower has been known to blush when the subject of slug pellets is brought up. Just occasionally, they might admit, when they're really desperate and the cats are out of potential harms way, they'll use " a tiny few". We all have limits, it seems, and they often come in bright blue crystal form.


It's all about priorities. I could either provide five rows of delicious winter greens to feed us through the winter or make a small contribution to the life cycle of the Large and Small White butterfly in a corner of rural Kent. My response to this moral dilemma? To dance on their little Lepidoptera graves. But then I was particular upset about the kales because, for once I had actually been sensible. When I planted the seedlings back in July, I covered them with Agralan mesh I bought on the internet. This stuff looks highly professional ­ ie makes your garden look like a rubbbish tip ­ so I had faith. Clearly, though, the mesh has acted less as a barrier and more as a comfy incubation zone for butterfly life. Next year I could build a high wooden frame to drape the mesh over and hermetically seal the edges, thereby resulting in a full crop of kale and removing the need for secateur-dissection altogether. Really, though, wheres the fun in that?